The idea that dogs are unclean is based on hadiths such as these:
“Once Gabriel promised the Prophet (that he would visit him, but Gabriel did not come) and later on he said, ‘We, angels, do not enter a house which contains a picture or a dog.’” — Sahih Bukhari 4.54.50
“Abdullah (b. Umar) (Allah be pleased with them) reported: Allah’s Messenger (may peace be upon him) ordered the killing of dogs and we would send (men) in Medina and its corners and we did not spare any dog that we did not kill, so much so that we killed the dog that accompanied the wet she-camel belonging to the people of the desert.” — Sahih Muslim 3811
The idea that Sharia actually allows for guide dogs is based on this hadith:
“Ibn Mughaffal reported: The Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) ordered killing of the dogs, and then said: What about them, i. e. about other dogs? and then granted concession (to keep) the dog for hunting and the dog for (the security) of the herd, and said: When the dog licks the utensil, wash it seven times, and rub it with earth the eighth time.” — Sahih Muslim 551
“Blind man sues Arab restaurant for rejecting guide dog entry, Sharia law,” Jerusalem Post, February 19, 2021:
A blind Arab man sued a restaurant that refused to allow him to enter accompanied by a guide dog, according to a press statement from the Commission on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. The lawsuit asserts that refusal to allow the guide dog to enter goes against Sharia law.
Islamic law expert Dr. Ihab Sharif submitted his opinion to a Magistrate’s Court in Netanya on behalf of the Equal Rights Commission for Persons with Disabilities, stated that Islamic law (Sharia) has a positive view of guide dogs. A guide dog is a vital need for a blind person and therefore, according to Sharia, he is allowed to own such a dog and society should allow him to enter with his dog in public places, including mosques.
Yet, the restaurant owner claimed that the dog is considered an unclean animal according to Islamic Sharia, so despite his vitality to the blind man who tried to enter the restaurant with him, he refused to allow it….
rooare says
Probably did the blind man a favor bc Mohammad didn’t use toilet paper either.
b.a. freeman says
U are correct, sir; muhammed had stinky fingers on his left hand from using rocks to wipe his a**!
BlackSabbath says
So it was who Mohammaded who started Rock and Roll. After wiping his a**, he used to roll in mud. Until today, I thought Rock and Roll was started by Chuck Berry.
Check Burry says
The majority of todays people have discovered soap, 7 wash their dogs,maybe not some in certain cults, about 1400 years to catch up.
Check Burry says
7, translate to &
Spiro says
If you really understand Islam it becomes clear the animals aren’t the unclean ones
There is a passage where one of the apostles is told ” I have never created anything unclean ” sorry I can’t remember the exact location
But this should make some people think
AnnChristine Blunsom says
Ridiculous people. The Moslem always seem to hate the treasures and animals we love I wish the hell they would all get out of our faces and leave us to get on with our lives No wonder they are still living in the sixth Century As we move forward they never catch up and remain in their miserable hideous lives
tim gallagher says
I agree with your comment, AnnChristine, about how Islam hates what we treasure. Islam and Muslims just seem to see everything in some kind of sick, upside down way. Most people see dogs as very pleasant animals, friendly, sociable animals (probably because of being pack animals) and “man’s best friend”, but, no, Muslims, being the perverse and evil types of people that they are, come up the view that dogs are no good. Of course, it was that evil creature, Muhammad, murderer and paedophile and all round nasty human being, that came up with the bizarre notion that dogs are no good, which is so totally out of step with the attitude of most normal human beings.
Anne Smith says
It is said that Mohammed hated dogs because he was unable to rob traveller’s camps where they had dogs who barked a warning.
Spiro says
That sounds like the real reason of course the false profit could never admit that
tim gallagher says
That sounds about right, Anne. What a lowlife creature this supposed “prophet” was, although I doubt that Muhammad even existed – I think he was made up by other evil creeps later on. Islam is so sick and weird. Most people recognise dogs as being “man’s best friend” ( I like all animals and I have mainly had cats and feed a couple of stray cats these days) but Islam tells Muslims to take a totally different and nasty viewpoint and to see dogs as animals to be hated. To me, it is just one more sickening aspect of Islam.
PRCS says
THE BOTTOM LINE
As this event occurred in Israel–which is NOT governed in accordance with Islamic law–what does Israeli law state about guide dogs in public places (a restaurant in particular)?
Peter Buckley says
Even on the issue of dogs, Islam makes victims of its own followers:
https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p04p4n6m
Westman says
How do we know this wasn’t just an arrogant elitist angel substituting his own preferences? Or, Muhammad’s frustration at dogs for alerting villages to his attacks?
What we know for certain is, it’s all BS. Pictures on walls have no effect on anything. And women stopping prayers in front of praying, “men”? That could only have been swallowed by the Ummah when Muhammad & Co falsely believed the world was flat. The world is a sphere dear believers.
When a Muslim prays toward Mecca from any distance such as Africa, the Americas, the EU, Russia, China, Japan, etc, a straight line to Mecca goes right down through the ground, under any object such as a woman or dog. And remember, the ground is “clean” by Muhammad’s own instructions to clean a canine-corrupted utinsel with earth.
Muhammad didn’t like women because they couldn’t fight in his invading bands and were likely to want their men alive and home taking care of their famies. For him, men fought and obtained booty and women were more like the booty.
P.S.
Western humanity just landed a device on Mars because they don’t use “holy” works in place of empirical science. The US, China, and India are all planning to put humans on Mars. Islam will never catch up.
Keith O says
Islam is planning on sending someone to the sun, but they will go at night so they don’t get burnt!
b.a. freeman says
😀
Spiro says
?
E T says
LOL TY
gravenimage says
I’m a woman, an artist, and I have pets and do animal rescue–oh, and an Anti-Jihadist…
Steve says
Dogs are allowed if they’re working dogs. When those rules were made there were no guide dogs. The dogs saliva is najis so while that wouldn’t make a lot of difference herding sheep in a restaurant it means much more. That’s what Islamic expert isn’t revealing.
Keith O says
Mudslimes not liking dogs, this is, in my book, just one more reason to dislike islam with a passion. Saw some of the local mudslimes in town the other day, it was the first time my Dingo had seen one, all the robes etc. My fur child growled and snarled at them, given that the only one he has had that reaction to in the past was an ice addict!!!
Well, the old saying goes, “if my dog don’t trust you, I will never trust you”.
As a side note, why would an Angel, who is one of the creators creatures, refuse to enter a house that has a dog? which is of course another of the creators creatures!
Reminds me of the scenes from the Terminator franchise.
E T says
A man in Key West, Florida, stopped me on the street and told me he would never get a dog like mine – a border collie – he said he would never want a dog smarter than him. LOL. That might explain what Muslims think.
OLD GUY says
I’d rather have a dog for a friend than most muslims/islamics.
gravenimage says
Israel: Restaurant owner forbids blind man to enter with guide dog, says dogs unclean according to Sharia
…………
This is both illegal and inhumane.