Elon Musk is asking a panel of judges if he can ditch his court-ordered ‘Twitter Sitter’ for Tesla-related posts saying it ‘chills’ his free speech

Bob Van Voris

Chris Dolmetsch

Bloomberg

A lawyer for Elon Musk asked a federal appeals court in New York to throw out his 2018 agreement with US regulators requiring a <a href="https://fortune.com/company/tesla/" target="_blank">Tesla</a> Inc. lawyer to screen all his company-related <a href="https://fortune.com/company/twitter/" target="_blank">Twitter</a> posts, calling it an illegal limitation on his free-speech rights.<div class="paywall-selector"></div><div class="paywall">



Musk, Tesla’s chief executive officer and now the owner of Twitter Inc., has claimed that the agreement with the US Securities and Exchange Commission violates the First Amendment to the Constitution and that the SEC is harassing him.&nbsp;



The requirement “chills Mr. Musk’s speech,” limiting his ability to make statements about Tesla that don’t violate any securities laws, Ellyde R. Thompson, an attorney representing the Tesla CEO, told the panel.



Last year, US District Judge Lewis Liman refused to release Musk from the deal and end his “Twitter Sitter” requirement, saying the CEO was “simply bemoaning that he felt like he had to agree to it at the time” and now “wishes that he had not.” Liman also denied Musk’s effort to block an SEC subpoena seeking information on his tweets.



Thompson on Thursday asked a three-judge panel of the federal appeals court in Manhattan to reverse the ruling and throw out the deal, or at least modify it.



“The pre-approval provision is a classic prior restraint that the Constitution forbids: a government-imposed muzzle on Mr. Musk’s speech before it is made,” Musk’s legal team said in court papers.&nbsp;



Musk has been battling with the SEC over his social media posts since he tweeted in 2018 that he had “funding secured” to take Tesla private, sending shares of the electric-car maker surging. The regulator sued, claiming Musk and Tesla had misled shareholders. Musk and Tesla settled with the SEC, with each paying $20 million and agreeing that Musk’s Tesla-related tweets would be reviewed before he posts them.



In his decision, Liman ruled that Musk willingly waived his First Amendment right to tweet without restraint, a finding Musk denied in his appeal brief.



“Mr. Musk could not possibly have known the circumstances and consequences of the pre-approval provision because the provision applies to future speech about circumstances no one could anticipate in advance,” his lawyers wrote. But even if he did waive his rights, such a waiver is invalid and unenforceable, they said.



Jeffrey Berger, arguing for the SEC, told the judges there have been no significant changes since Musk agreed to screen his Tesla tweets and that the CEO had failed to show the deal has become “onerous or unworkable.”



“Those are the terms to which he agreed,” Berger said.&nbsp;



“Musk may no longer wish to comply with the preapproval process, and he may find it inconvenient at times, but he agreed to its terms and has not demonstrated any change in circumstances that makes it substantially more onerous or unworkable,” the SEC said in its appeal brief.



The regulator called Musk’s harassment claim “a significant exaggeration.”



“There is no government censor here,” Berger told the panel. “There is an agreement that Tesla will review its CEO’s communications before they become public. The agreement here does not preclude him from speaking about any topic.”



The case is US Securities and Exchange Commission v. Musk, 22-1291, Second US Circuit Court of Appeals (Manhattan).</div>

“The pre-approval provision is a classic prior restraint that the Constitution forbids: a government-imposed muzzle on Mr. Musk’s speech before it is made,” Musk’s legal team said in court papers.

Elon Musk asks judges to ditch 'Twitter Sitter'

Did your workplace make our list of the World's Most Admired Companies?
<a href="https://fortune.com/ranking/worlds-most-admired-companies/?&itm_source=fortune&itm_medium=article_tout&itm_campaign=DecJanMag">Explore this year's list.</a>

F-Wire

Elon Musk

Tech

Finance

Elon Musk is asking a panel of judges if he can ditch his court-ordered 'Twitter Sitter' for Tesla-related posts saying it 'chills' his free speech

Elon Musk asks judges to ditch 'Twitter Sitter' | Fortune

Josh Wingrove

US President Donald Trump speaks during an executive order signing ceremony in the Oval Office of the White House in Washington, DC, US, on Thursday, March 6, 2025.

Trump open to again extending TikTok deadline if necessary

/2025/03/06/trump-open-to-again-extending-tiktok-deadline-if-necessary/

Rita Nazareth

A trader works at the New York Stock Exchange in New York, the United States

Stocks sink as tariff back-and-forth roils trading: markets wrap

/2025/03/06/stocks-sink-as-tariff-back-and-forth-roils-trading-markets-wrap/

The Associated Press

Taiwan’s president insists TSMC’s $100 billion U.S. chip investment wasn’t because of pressure from the Trump administration

/2025/03/06/taiwans-president-insists-tsmcs-100-billion-u-s-chip-investment-wasnt-because-of-pressure-from-the-trump-administration/

Jaewon Kang

Worker in orange Home Depot apron scans a purchase

Home Depot turns to AI to answer online shoppers’ questions

/2025/03/06/home-depot-ai-online-chatbot/

Sage Lazzaro

An image of a hand holding a mobile phone displaying the logo of Anthropic's Claude AI chatbot against a backdrop similarly showing the Claude logo and the word "Claude."

Exclusive: Anthropic’s Claude 3.7 Sonnet is the most secure model yet, an independent audit suggests

/2025/03/06/exclusive-anthropics-claude-3-7-sonnet-is-the-most-secure-model-yet-an-independent-audit-suggests/

John Nay

Troy A. Paredes

When regulations hinder entrepreneurship, we all lose out. AI can help regulators do a better job—and get out of the way

/2025/03/06/how-ai-can-help-regulators-get-out-of-entrepreneurs-way/

Emma Burleigh

MrBeast is the world's top YouTuber with an $85 million empire—but he says the average person 'would be miserable' living his life

https://fortune.com/2025/03/06/mrbeast-youtube-empire-miserable-ceo-stress/?itm_source=parsely-api

Greg McKenna

The architect of Trump’s first tax cuts says the plan to scoop out overtime pay and Social Security from taxes is 'very expensive' but tips are feasible

https://fortune.com/2025/03/06/architect-trump-first-round-tax-cuts-plan-exempt-overtime-social-security-taxes/?itm_source=parsely-api

Irina Ivanova

Elon Musk's DOGE slapped a $1 limit on government credit cards and now workers say they can’t do their jobs

https://fortune.com/2025/03/05/doge-federal-credit-card-elon-musk/?itm_source=parsely-api

Luisa Beltran

As JPMorgan Chase enforces a 5-day RTO, staffers complain about too few desks, spotty Wi-Fi, and sneezing, sick coworkers

https://fortune.com/2025/03/06/jpmorgan-chase-jamie-dimon-union-rto-wall-street/?itm_source=parsely-api

Stuart Dyos

Elon Musk's offer to bring home stranded astronauts never reached the space station, say NASA astronauts who are still in orbit after 9 months

https://fortune.com/2025/03/06/elon-musk-spacex-nasa-astronauts-stranded-iss-boeing-starliner-barry-wilmore-sunita-williams/?itm_source=parsely-api

Apple cofounder Steve Wozniak lays into Elon Musk’s ‘mass firings’: ‘I don’t know what got into his head’

https://fortune.com/2025/03/06/apple-cofounder-steve-wozniak-lays-into-elon-musks-mass-firings-i-dont-know-what-got-into-his-head/?itm_source=parsely-api